data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c97f0/c97f0c96fb7f7bff3a74ade3e2240b3ec411f30e" alt=""
When I bought these books, I was rather expecting books of new spells for Magic-Users and for Clerics. This is not what I got, and under other circumstances, I might have been somewhat annoyed. (To be fair, the write-up on Lulu looking back does indicate that this is the case, but perhaps not clearly enough.)
However, I have actually come to the conclusion that these have the potential to be extremely useful. What you have here, quite simply, are copies of the spells from the Swords and Wizardry Core Rules, for Magic-Users and Clerics respectively. The use is simple – hand a copy of the relevant book to each spell-using character, and he has his own description of the spells without having to leaf through the rulebook. This plays into a line from the 'Primer for Old School Gaming', which notes that in this style of play, the only character liable to be referring to the rules at all would be a spellcaster. And this makes that rather simpler.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3e725/3e725fc27d75793d31be13741e065761a82a0030" alt=""
Buy Book of Wizardry at Lulu.
Buy Book of the Divine at Lulu.
Great review as usual, and thanks for taking the time to do these. There is a LOT of material coming out these days, and no regular, dedicated source to evaluate it. Keep it up!
ReplyDelete